Synthesized answer
The anticipated criticisms suggest that the societal and religious norms of the time expected religious writings by a divine to be serious and sober, avoiding both levity and harsh criticism. The charge that the work is "lighter than may become a divine" indicates an expectation of scholarly gravity from religious figures [1]. Similarly, the accusation that it is "more biting than may beseem the modesty of a Christian" implies that Christians were expected to be gentle and avoid sharp censure, especially in their writings [1].
These criticisms reveal a tension between the desire for decorum and the liberty of witty commentary on human foibles. Erasmus counters by noting that liberty in making "smart, witty reflections on the common errors of mankind" was historically permitted as long as it did not become licentious [2]. He argues that his work, by criticizing vices without naming individuals, is more of a teaching or admonishment than a biting attack [2]. He also defends the lightness of his approach by citing numerous great authors who employed similar "toys" or forms of recreation in their writing, suggesting that study should also have its diversions [3]. The passages do not…
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
dible affability and sweetness of temper that you both can and delight to carry yourself to all men a man of all hours. Wherefore you will not only with good will accept this small declamation, but take upon you the defense of it, for as much as being dedicated to you, it is now no longer mine but yours. But perhaps there will not be wanting some wranglers that may cavil and charge me, partly that these toys are lighter than may become a divine, and partly more biting than may beseem the modesty of a Christian, and consequently exclaim that I resemble the ancient comedy, or another…
own cause, I have praised folly, but not altogether foolishly. And now to say somewhat to that other cavil, of biting. This liberty was ever permitted to all men's wits, to make their smart, witty reflections on the common errors of mankind, and that too without offense, as long as this liberty does not run into licentiousness; which makes me the more admire the tender ears of the men of this age, that can away with solemn titles. No, you'll meet with some so preposterously religious that they will sooner endure the broadest scoffs even against Christ himself than hear the Pope or a…
f a Christian, and consequently exclaim that I resemble the ancient comedy, or another Lucian, and snarl at everything. But I would have them whom the lightness or foolery of the argument may offend to consider that mine is not the first of this kind, but the same thing that has been often practiced even by great authors: when Homer, so many ages since, did the like with the battle of frogs and mice; Virgil, with the gnat and puddings; Ovid, with the nut; when Polycrates and his corrector Isocrates extolled tyranny; Glauco, injustice; Favorinus, deformity and the quartan ague;…
therefore, if there shall happen to be anyone that shall say he is hit, he will but discover either his guilt or fear. Saint Jerome sported in this kind with more freedom and greater sharpness, not sparing sometimes men's very name. But I, besides that I have wholly avoided it, I have so moderated my style that the understanding reader will easily perceive my endeavors herein were rather to make mirth than bite. Nor have I, after the example of Juvenal, raked up that forgotten sink of filth and ribaldry, but laid before you things rather ridiculous than dishonest. And now, if there be…
se. For what injustice is it that when we allow every course of life its recreation, that study only should have none? Especially when such toys are not without their serious matter, and foolery is so handled that the reader that is not altogether thick-skulled may reap more benefit from it than from some men's crabbish and specious arguments. As when one, with long study and great pains, patches many pieces together on the praise of rhetoric or philosophy; another makes a panegyric to a prince; another encourages him to a war against the Turks; another tells you what will become of…
More questions about this book
- Erasmus, a respected "divine," chooses to "make some sport with the praise of folly." Explain, as if to someone unfamiliar with the concept, why this choice might be considered paradoxical or even provocative for his contemporary audience.
- How does Erasmus's detailed portrayal of Thomas More's character and his decision to dedicate "The Praise of Folly" to him serve as more than just flattery, acting instead as a strategic rhetorical move to frame the reader's interpretation of the work?
- Erasmus defends his work by citing ancient authors who "practiced" similar "toys." What specific literary tradition or genre is he referring to with examples like Homer's battle of frogs and mice, and how does understanding its historical purpose help us anticipate the likely satirical or critical approach of "The Praise of Folly"?
- The playful connection between Thomas More's surname and the Greek word *Moriae* (folly) is presented as the initial spark for the work. Beyond simple wordplay, what deeper implications might this seemingly trivial starting point suggest about the nature of wit, wisdom, or even the very definition of "folly" within the context of the dedication?