Synthesized answer
Erasmus defends his work by citing authors who "practiced" similar "toys" as precedent [1]. These examples, such as Homer's "battle of frogs and mice," Virgil's "gnat and puddings," and Ovid's "nut," suggest a tradition of playful, often allegorical or mock-heroic writing [1]. These works, by treating seemingly trivial subjects with seriousness or by satirizing human foibles through animal characters or absurd scenarios, served a form of recreation that could also contain "serious matter" [1, 2].
Understanding the historical purpose of this tradition helps anticipate the satirical or critical approach of "The Praise of Folly." These authors used seemingly lighthearted or foolish themes to explore deeper truths or to critique society and human behavior indirectly [2]. For example, Lucian and Apuleius, by writing about an ass, and Plutarch, with his dialogue between Ulysses and Gryllus, likely used these narratives to comment on human nature and wisdom [1]. This approach allows the author to discourse on trifles in a way that can yield benefit to the reader, suggesting that "Praise of Folly" will likely use humor and satire to critique folly and perhaps expose the folly of those…
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
f a Christian, and consequently exclaim that I resemble the ancient comedy, or another Lucian, and snarl at everything. But I would have them whom the lightness or foolery of the argument may offend to consider that mine is not the first of this kind, but the same thing that has been often practiced even by great authors: when Homer, so many ages since, did the like with the battle of frogs and mice; Virgil, with the gnat and puddings; Ovid, with the nut; when Polycrates and his corrector Isocrates extolled tyranny; Glauco, injustice; Favorinus, deformity and the quartan ague;…
se. For what injustice is it that when we allow every course of life its recreation, that study only should have none? Especially when such toys are not without their serious matter, and foolery is so handled that the reader that is not altogether thick-skulled may reap more benefit from it than from some men's crabbish and specious arguments. As when one, with long study and great pains, patches many pieces together on the praise of rhetoric or philosophy; another makes a panegyric to a prince; another encourages him to a war against the Turks; another tells you what will become of…
you, such as you are wont to prick up to jugglers, fools, and buffoons, and such as our friend Midas once gave to Pan. For I am disposed awhile to play the sophist with you; not of their sort who nowadays boozle young men's heads with certain empty notions and curious trifles, yet teach them nothing but a more than womanish obstinacy of scolding: but I'll imitate those ancients who, that they might the better avoid that infamous appellation of _sophi_ or _wise_, chose rather to be called sophists. Their business was to celebrate the praises of the gods and valiant men. And the like…
what an excellent thing this folly is, whose very counterfeit and semblance only has got such praise from the learned. But more candidly does that fat plump "Epicurean bacon-hog," Horace, for so he calls himself, bid us "mingle our purposes with folly;" and whereas he adds the word _bravem_, short, perhaps to help out the verse, he might as well have let it alone; and again, "'Tis a pleasant thing to play the fool in the right season;" and in another place, he had rather "be accounted a dotterel and sot than to be wise and made mouths at." And Telemachus in Homer, whom the poet…
, to wit, that of rational creatures or brutes, he intended no other in it than to show the apparent folly of the sex. For if perhaps any of them goes about to be thought wiser than the rest, what else does she do but play the fool twice, as if a man should "teach a cow to dance," "a thing quite against the hair." For as it doubles the crime if anyone should put a disguise upon Nature, or endeavor to bring her to that she will in no wise bear, according to that proverb of the Greeks, "An ape is an ape, though clad in scarlet;" so a woman is a woman still, that is to say foolish, let…
More questions about this book
- Erasmus, a respected "divine," chooses to "make some sport with the praise of folly." Explain, as if to someone unfamiliar with the concept, why this choice might be considered paradoxical or even provocative for his contemporary audience.
- How does Erasmus's detailed portrayal of Thomas More's character and his decision to dedicate "The Praise of Folly" to him serve as more than just flattery, acting instead as a strategic rhetorical move to frame the reader's interpretation of the work?
- The text anticipates criticisms that the work is "lighter than may become a divine" and "more biting than may beseem the modesty of a Christian." What do these anticipated criticisms reveal about the societal and religious norms Erasmus was operating within, and how might his writing inherently challenge or comment on these norms?
- The playful connection between Thomas More's surname and the Greek word *Moriae* (folly) is presented as the initial spark for the work. Beyond simple wordplay, what deeper implications might this seemingly trivial starting point suggest about the nature of wit, wisdom, or even the very definition of "folly" within the context of the dedication?