← In Praise of Folly

Question

Erasmus, a respected "divine," chooses to "make some sport with the praise of folly." Explain, as if to someone unfamiliar with the concept, why this choice might be considered paradoxical or even provocative for his contemporary audience.

Synthesized answer

Erasmus, a respected "divine," chooses to "make some sport with the praise of folly" [1]. For his contemporary audience, this choice would be paradoxical and provocative because it goes against the expected solemnity and seriousness associated with religious scholars. Presenting "folly" in a jocular manner, even when the author claims to be a "divine," could be seen as undermining the gravity of important matters or appearing unlearned and insipid [1, 2].

Furthermore, the passages suggest that while some esteemed authors and figures from antiquity, such as Homer, Virgil, Ovid, Seneca, and even Cicero, engaged in praising seemingly foolish or trivial subjects [3, 4], the authority of these classical examples might not hold sway with a Christian audience. The idea of a "divine" engaging in such "lightness or foolery" might also be met with criticism, as they might "snarl at everything" or find it a "foolish and insolent thing to praise one's self" [3, 2]. The passages do not explicitly detail the specific contemporary societal expectations of a "divine" beyond implying a preference for seriousness and a potential aversion to self-praise or jocularity on serious matters.

Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.

From the book

ou I ever found in your company; than which, let me perish if in all my life I ever met with anything more delectable. And therefore, being satisfied that something was to be done, and that that time was no wise proper for any serious matter, I resolved to make some sport with the praise of folly. But who the devil put that in your head? you'll say. The first thing was your surname of More, which comes so near the word _Moriae_ (folly) as you are far from the thing. And that you are so, all the world will clear you. In the next place, I conceived this exercise of wit would not…
Passage [2]
you, such as you are wont to prick up to jugglers, fools, and buffoons, and such as our friend Midas once gave to Pan. For I am disposed awhile to play the sophist with you; not of their sort who nowadays boozle young men's heads with certain empty notions and curious trifles, yet teach them nothing but a more than womanish obstinacy of scolding: but I'll imitate those ancients who, that they might the better avoid that infamous appellation of _sophi_ or _wise_, chose rather to be called sophists. Their business was to celebrate the praises of the gods and valiant men. And the like…
Passage [10]
f a Christian, and consequently exclaim that I resemble the ancient comedy, or another Lucian, and snarl at everything. But I would have them whom the lightness or foolery of the argument may offend to consider that mine is not the first of this kind, but the same thing that has been often practiced even by great authors: when Homer, so many ages since, did the like with the battle of frogs and mice; Virgil, with the gnat and puddings; Ovid, with the nut; when Polycrates and his corrector Isocrates extolled tyranny; Glauco, injustice; Favorinus, deformity and the quartan ague;…
Passage [4]
what an excellent thing this folly is, whose very counterfeit and semblance only has got such praise from the learned. But more candidly does that fat plump "Epicurean bacon-hog," Horace, for so he calls himself, bid us "mingle our purposes with folly;" and whereas he adds the word _bravem_, short, perhaps to help out the verse, he might as well have let it alone; and again, "'Tis a pleasant thing to play the fool in the right season;" and in another place, he had rather "be accounted a dotterel and sot than to be wise and made mouths at." And Telemachus in Homer, whom the poet…
Passage [184]
r can I give you any reason why it should seem so strange when Saint Paul imputes a kind of folly even to God himself. "The foolishness of God," says he, "is wiser than men." Though yet I must confess that origin upon the place denies that this foolishness may be resembled to the uncertain judgment of men; of which kind is, that "the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness." But why am I so careful to no purpose that I thus run on to prove my matter by so many testimonies? when in those mystical Psalms Christ speaking to the Father says openly, "Thou knowest my…
Passage [202]

More questions about this book