Synthesized answer
Johnson describes the English language before his work as "copious without order, and energetick without rules" [2]. To address this, he relied on "general grammar" and the "perusal of our writers" [1]. By noting whatever might "ascertain or illustrate any word or phrase," he accumulated materials for his dictionary [1]. He then reduced these materials to method by establishing rules based on "experience and analogy" [1]. "Experience" grew through practice and observation, while "analogy" was evident in some words, though obscure in others [1].
This methodology directly confronted the language's chaos by imposing order through systematic perusal and rule-making based on observed patterns. The "perplexity to be disentangled, and confusion to be regulated" was approached by making "choice ... out of boundless variety, without any established principle of selection" [2], and by detecting "adulterations ... without a settled test of purity" [2]. His work aimed to settle orthography, display analogy, regulate structures, and ascertain signification [3]. This implies Johnson viewed language as possessing an underlying structure, even if it was obscured by disorder and lack of…
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
ion to be rejected or received, without the suffrages of any writers of classical reputation or acknowledged authority. Having therefore no assistance but from general grammar, I applied myself to the perusal of our writers; and noting whatever might be of use to ascertain or illustrate any word or phrase, accumulated in time the materials of a dictionary, which, by degrees, I reduced to method, establishing to myself, in the progress of the work, such rules as experience and analogy suggested to me; experience, which practice and observation were continually increasing; and analogy,…
he lexicographer can only hope to escape reproach, and even this negative recompense has been yet granted to very few. I have, notwithstanding this discouragement, attempted a dictionary of the English language, which, while it was employed in the cultivation of every species of literature, has itself been hitherto neglected; suffered to spread, under the direction of chance, into wild exuberance; resigned to the tyranny of time and fashion; and exposed to the corruptions of ignorance, and caprices of innovation. When I took the first survey of my undertaking, I found our…
d equivocally, I receive them in either sense; when they are metaphorical, I adopt them in their primitive acceptation. I have sometimes, though rarely, yielded to the temptation of exhibiting a genealogy of sentiments, by shewing how one authour copied the thoughts and diction of another: such quotations are indeed little more than repetitions, which might justly be censured, did they not gratify the mind, by affording a kind of intellectual history. The various syntactical structures occurring in the examples have been carefully noted; the licence or negligence with which many words…
the language; who do not teach men how they should think, but relate how they have hitherto expressed their thoughts. The imperfect sense of some examples I lamented, but could not remedy, and hope they will be compensated by innumerable passages selected with propriety, and preserved with exactness; some shining with sparks of imagination, and some replete with treasures of wisdom. The orthography and etymology, though imperfect, are not imperfect for want of care, but because care will not always be successful, and recollection or information come too late for use.
f kindred words be found such as may easily pass into each other, or such as may both be referred to one general idea. The etymology, so far as it is yet known, was easily found in the volumes where it is particularly and professedly delivered; and, by proper attention to the rules of derivation, the orthography was soon adjusted. But to COLLECT the WORDS of our language was a task of greater difficulty: the deficiency of dictionaries was immediately apparent; and when they were exhausted, what was yet wanting must be sought by fortuitous and unguided excursions into books,…
More questions about this book
- Johnson opens by lamenting the "fate of those who toil at the lower employments of life." How does he specifically illustrate this "fate" through the lens of a dictionary writer, and what deeper commentary on societal values or the nature of intellectual labor does this reveal?
- In addressing orthography, Johnson distinguishes between "inherent irregularities" and those born of "ignorance or negligence." What is the practical significance of this distinction for a dictionary maker attempting to standardize a language, and what does it suggest about his criteria for what constitutes legitimate linguistic variation?
- Johnson states that "every other authour may aspire to praise; the lexicographer can only hope to escape reproach." If external reward is so scarce, what internal motivations or intellectual commitments must have driven Johnson to undertake and persevere with such an immense and thankless task?
- Consider Johnson's detailed account of the "perplexity" and "confusion" he faced. If you were advising a modern language regulator on standardizing a new, rapidly evolving digital language, which of Johnson's challenges and solutions would be most relevant, and which might be entirely inapplicable in today's context?