Summary
Samuel Johnson’s *A Dictionary of the English Language* seeks to regulate the English language, which he found to be "copious without order, and energetick without rules." He aimed to address the "perplexity to be disentangled, and confusion to be regulated" caused by English words being "resigned to the tyranny of time and fashion; and exposed to the corruptions of ignorance, and caprices of innovation." By systematically selecting and defining words, tracing irregular inflections, and illustrating meanings with example sentences from classical authors, Johnson aimed to establish a standard for English, analogous to preserving a nation's constitution.
Johnson’s dictionary establishes principles for selection, definition, and orthography. He prioritizes clarity and utility, choosing passages that "determine [a word's] meaning" and preferring the "primitive acceptation" of metaphorical words. His work also distinguishes inherent irregularities in the language from those introduced by "ignorance or negligence of later writers." Ultimately, Johnson sought to preserve the English language and prevent its "degeneration," contributing to the field of philology with this comprehensive effort.
Key concepts
- Adulterations — Words that have been corrupted and need to be identified and removed from the language.
- Established principle of selection — The need for a systematic method to choose words for inclusion in a dictionary, rather than arbitrary choice.
- Settled orthography — The effort to standardize the spelling of English words, distinguishing between inherent irregularities and those caused by later writers.
- Genealogy of sentiments — Tracing the lineage of ideas and word usage from one author to another, providing an intellectual history.
- Propriety — The correct and appropriate use of words, which Johnson endeavored to direct through exhibiting different word combinations.
From the book
Of many words it is difficult to say whether they were immediately
Even in words of which the derivation is apparent, I have been
from the primitive, as explain and explanation, repeat and repetition. Some combinations of letters having the same power are used
Popular questions readers ask
- Johnson opens by lamenting the "fate of those who toil at the lower employments of life." How does he specifically illustrate this "fate" through the lens of a dictionary writer, and what deeper commentary on societal values or the nature of intellectual labor does this reveal?
- Johnson describes the English language as "copious without order, and energetick without rules" before he began his work. How did his chosen methodology—relying on "general grammar" and "perusal of our writers," guided by "experience and analogy"—directly address these specific chaotic characteristics, and what does this imply about his view of language's underlying structure?
- In addressing orthography, Johnson distinguishes between "inherent irregularities" and those born of "ignorance or negligence." What is the practical significance of this distinction for a dictionary maker attempting to standardize a language, and what does it suggest about his criteria for what constitutes legitimate linguistic variation?
- Johnson states that "every other authour may aspire to praise; the lexicographer can only hope to escape reproach." If external reward is so scarce, what internal motivations or intellectual commitments must have driven Johnson to undertake and persevere with such an immense and thankless task?
- Consider Johnson's detailed account of the "perplexity" and "confusion" he faced. If you were advising a modern language regulator on standardizing a new, rapidly evolving digital language, which of Johnson's challenges and solutions would be most relevant, and which might be entirely inapplicable in today's context?