Synthesized answer
When a historical work is curated and released by family members after the author's death, particularly concerning the author's own political era, there are potential implications stemming from their role. The author's sons were entrusted with his papers and faced questions about how to present his memoirs to the public [1]. They felt a "deep sense of special unfitness arising from natural partiality" when considering their duty to continue his history or revise his unfinished and unrevised memoirs [1].
The sons were faced with a dilemma: either publish the memoirs as a fragment without revision, or undertake the task of continuing the history, supplying gaps, and revising the work themselves [1]. The author himself had resolved that no part of his writing would be published in his lifetime and never revised what he had written, which closed abruptly in 1833-34 due to illness and his own failing health [3]. The editors state that their work on this volume has been "inconsiderable," limited to correcting inadvertencies, dividing it into chapters, furnishing a title, and adding a few footnotes [2]. They chose to publish it "in the form in which it was left by the writer" [2].
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
mere graces of composition, the _labor limæ_ was continually postponed, and the "flighty purpose" was never o'ertaken. When, after his death, the subject of the disposition of these memoirs was presented to his sons, to whom his papers had been intrusted, they were embarrassed by questions as to the manner and form in which it was their duty to give them the publicity intended by their author. Should they, notwithstanding unaffected distrust of their qualifications, and a deep sense of special unfitness arising from natural partiality, undertake to continue the history of their…
together, it has been thought best to publish it without further delay in the form in which it was left by the writer. The subject is of peculiar interest at this time when our country, having suffered the rude shock and disorder of civil war, and our free and popular institutions having sustained with admirable firmness and substantial triumph a more fearful trial than any to which they had before been subjected, the sacred and momentous duty is devolved on patriots and good citizens throughout our borders to reconstruct whatever valuable parts have been thrown down, to restore what…
d this limitation, he resolved, at the start, that no part of what he might write should be published in his lifetime. The work which he had commenced, was thus exposed to frequent interruption, even by unimportant accidents, and at length was altogether arrested by the serious illness of a member of his family, and by the failure of his own health, which rapidly supervened. It resulted that the recorded memoirs of his life and times closed abruptly when he had brought them down to the date of 1833-34, and that he never revised for publication what he had written. There is…
family memorials, his inclination to undertake it was evidence of a general sympathy with, or at least respect for, Mr. Van Buren's character and public career sufficient to authorize the relinquishment to him of the materials in their possession. Accordingly the fragmentary memoirs, with all the correspondence and other manuscripts applicable to his purpose, and within their reach, were committed to Mr. Hunt, by Mr. Van Buren's representatives, with entire satisfaction and confidence that they will be used with fidelity and skill in the construction of the work he has undertaken,--a…
s death, and in the course of our repeated conversations he dwelt long and particularly upon these early transactions. I attributed the circumstance at the time to a desire, consistent with his very genial disposition, to gratify my curiosity, which was strong and not concealed; and it did not occur to me that he might have had other views, until, after my return home, I received his long letter avowedly written for the purpose for which I now use it, "to throw light on history, and to recall that into the path of truth when he was no more, nor those whom it might offend." In…
More questions about this book
- The introduction describes this text as a "digression" from a much larger work. How might this structural detail inform a reader's approach to understanding the depth and focus of Van Buren's specific inquiry into political parties?
- Van Buren began writing twelve years into his retirement, induced by friends who recognized his "extraordinary influence." How might this passage of time and his shift from active politics to "tranquil scenes" affect his perspective and objectivity when recounting the "Origin and Course of Political Parties?"
- The Cicero quote advocates for absolute truthfulness and impartiality in history. Given Van Buren's deep personal and professional involvement as an ex-President in the very political systems he is analyzing, how might a critical reader assess his potential challenges in adhering to this ideal?
- How might Van Buren's reported "ardor and a relish" for rural life and "hearty love of Nature" during his retirement contrast with, or even subtly influence, his retrospective account of the often contentious and intensely human-driven "incessant activity and excitement" of political party formation?