Summary
Martin Van Buren argues that two antagonistic national parties, with names changing over time but consistent core principles and membership, have perpetually divided the United States for a century. He contends that the success of the Republican, now Democratic, party is directly tied to its effective use of the caucus or convention system, a method that proved less essential for the Federal party and its successors. Van Buren seeks to explain the origin and history of these enduring divisions by examining the underlying principles that shaped them.
The book proposes that these political divisions are not superficial but stem from fundamental differences in opinion and feeling, with roots extending back to the English Revolution of 1688 and its application to the colonies, the grounds of the American Revolution, and the diverse character of early emigrants. Van Buren aims to provide an account of these origins from the perspective of the Republican or Democratic school, offering a counterpoint to existing explanations.
Key concepts
- Caucus or convention system — A method of political organization and action utilized by parties to achieve electoral success.
- Republican, now Democratic party — One of the two enduring political parties in the United States, whose success is linked to the caucus system.
- Federal party — The opposing enduring political party, which found the caucus system less critical to its unity and success.
- Principles established by the English Revolution of 1688 — Foundational ideas derived from this historical event that influenced political divisions in the colonies.
- Diverse character and feelings of emigrants — Variations among early settlers to different colonies that impacted their views on government.
From the book
The great principle first formally avowed by Rousseau, "that the right
Not being, however, for several generations, in a suitable condition,
That Revolution, which shattered, "past all surgery," the blasphemous
Popular questions readers ask
- The introduction describes this text as a "digression" from a much larger work. How might this structural detail inform a reader's approach to understanding the depth and focus of Van Buren's specific inquiry into political parties?
- Van Buren began writing twelve years into his retirement, induced by friends who recognized his "extraordinary influence." How might this passage of time and his shift from active politics to "tranquil scenes" affect his perspective and objectivity when recounting the "Origin and Course of Political Parties?"
- The Cicero quote advocates for absolute truthfulness and impartiality in history. Given Van Buren's deep personal and professional involvement as an ex-President in the very political systems he is analyzing, how might a critical reader assess his potential challenges in adhering to this ideal?
- This book was "EDITED BY HIS SONS" and published posthumously. What are the potential implications of a historical work being curated and released by family members after the author's death, particularly when the subject is the author's own political era?
- How might Van Buren's reported "ardor and a relish" for rural life and "hearty love of Nature" during his retirement contrast with, or even subtly influence, his retrospective account of the often contentious and intensely human-driven "incessant activity and excitement" of political party formation?