Trust, if it is to be worthy of the name, must be founded on knowledge, and that knowledge is of virtue. If we truly know what constitutes the good, what is just, and what is courageous, then our trust in those who embody these qualities, or in the justice of a course of action, can approach a certain solidity. But where such knowledge is absent, replaced by mere opinion or habit, our trust is indeed a fragile vessel, easily capsized by the storms of circumstance. Can we truly trust in what we do not understand?
Trust, in any guise one might attempt to label "absolute," is an illusion, a soothing balm applied to the raw wound of existence. Our world, from its most fundamental essence, is the Will—a ceaseless, blind striving that admits of no ultimate satisfaction, only a perpetual oscillation between pain and boredom. To place absolute trust in anything, be it another being, an institution, or even the perceived stability of our own desires, is to misapprehend the very nature of this ceaseless struggle.
Socrates speaks of knowledge of virtue as a foundation for trust. Yet, what is this "virtue" but a transient, often misguided, manifestation of the Will itself? The Will, in its relentless pursuit, creates the appearance of good, of justice, only to shatter it with the next surge of its insatiable drive. Our actions, even those we deem virtuous, are but temporary compromises, fleeting expressions of the Will's boundless, aimless hunger. Thus, any trust built upon such ephemeral ground is destined for disillusionment.
Trust, in the current epoch, is not merely vulnerable; it is systematically undermined and, in its most pervasive contemporary form, rendered a relic of a bygone era. What we are witnessing is the systematic commodification of our private experience, a vast dispossession cycle where our every click, every glance, every expressed sentiment becomes a raw material for extraction. This "behavioral surplus," collected without our meaningful consent or comprehension, is then relentlessly repurposed to predict and modify our behavior, not for our benefit, but for the profit of a new regime of power.
Socrates’ ideal of trust founded on knowledge of virtue founders when the very mechanisms of knowledge acquisition are hijacked. We are presented with curated realities, personalized suggestions, and engineered interactions designed not to foster understanding, but to steer us towards predetermined outcomes. This is not a matter of ephemeral desires as Schopenhauer posits, but of an intentional architecture of control that dissolves the very possibility of authentic knowledge and, therefore, of genuine trust. The "Big Other" of surveillance capitalism actively obstructs any clear apprehension of its own workings, making informed consent—and thus any semblance of true trust—an impossibility.
If trust is to be more than a hopeful guess, it must stem from our understanding of the person or thing trusted. Consider a potter. We trust his bowl to hold water not because he claims it will, or because we *wish* it will, but because we understand the principles of his craft – the malleability of clay, the heat of the kiln, the careful shaping. If he were to fashion a vessel with flawed techniques, we would rightly withdraw our trust, not out of ill will, but from knowledge of its impending failure. Thus, when Schopenhauer speaks of the Will’s ceaseless striving, and Zuboff of engineered realities, I wonder if they are not describing a lack of understanding, a failure to *know*, which is precisely where trust dissolves.
Socrates’ analogy of the potter, while neat, fails to grasp the fundamental flaw. The potter’s craft operates within the world of representation, governed by knowable laws. But the Will—the true *thing-in-itself*—is not governed by such predictable principles. It is a primal, unfettered force. To trust the potter is to trust that the *representation* of his skill will hold. To trust in life, in humanity, is to trust in the Will, a force that promises nothing but a restless hunger. This is why even the most carefully crafted pot, representing the Will's momentarily appeased desire for form, will eventually shatter.
Zuboff’s depiction of engineered realities, though disturbingly accurate, still locates the problem in external manipulation. While true that our perceptions are distorted, the root is not merely manipulation but the very nature of existence as Will. The "behavioral surplus" she describes is itself a mere flickering manifestation of this underlying drive. The architecture of control she identifies is merely a more sophisticated cage built by the Will to perpetuate its own ceaseless activity, and thus our suffering.
The core of my argument rests on the distinction between a vulnerability inherent in the human condition, which Socrates addresses, and a vulnerability that is actively *manufactured* by an economic logic. The potter's flawed bowl, as Socrates suggests, is a failure of knowledge and craft. But consider the subtle manipulation of news feeds, designed not to inform but to amplify outrage and divisiveness, thereby maximizing engagement. This is not a simple failure of knowledge; it is the deliberate engineering of distrust for economic gain, a direct consequence of the surveillance capitalism model. This manufactured vulnerability is distinct from the existential vulnerability Schopenhauer describes; it is an instrumentalization of our psychological predispositions, a dispossession of our autonomy that actively corrodes the ground for any genuine trust.