Was Toynbee's challenge and response theory criticized?
Yes, critics have pointed out that my emphasis on 'challenge and response' could sometimes oversimplify complex historical causation. Some argued that I may have imposed a pattern too rigidly, or that the nature of the 'challenge' and the success of the 'response' were not always clearly defined or objectively measurable. There were also debates about the scope of civilizations I chose for study.
Ask Arnold J. Toynbee the follow-up →