← The World of Thought in Ancient China

Question

The text mentions both Confucius's 'Agnosticism' and later 'Agnosticism the rule for literati.' How did this philosophical stance, appearing at different historical junctures, impact the development of religious practices and the social stratification of belief, differentiating the experience of the educated elite from that of 'the Masses'?

Synthesized answer

Confucius exhibited a "benevolent agnosticism," recognizing the existence of a spirit world but admitting he knew nothing definitive about it, as seen in his statement, "Respect the spirits, but keep them at a distance" [2]. This stance, alongside his emphasis on human morality and duties to neighbors, led to a weakening of supernatural beliefs [1, 5]. While Confucius himself performed sacrifices and believed in destiny, his philosophical approach, which prioritized earthly matters and subordinated duty to God to duty to one's neighbor, contributed to Confucianism becoming a system of morality rather than a religion [4, 5].

Later, after Chu Hsi materialized the Confucian Canon, agnosticism became "the rule for literati" [1]. This differentiated the educated elite's experience from that of "the Masses," who turned to "Buddhism and Taoism (both debased)" for their religious practices [1]. The provided passages do not explicitly detail how this division in philosophical stance, appearing at different historical junctures, impacted the social stratification of belief beyond this distinction between the literati and the masses, nor do they elaborate on the specific effects on…

Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.

From the book

Odes—Hou Chi and Parthenogenesis—Superstitions and Supernatural Manifestations—Sacrifice—Ancestral Worship—Filial Piety. Feudal Age (Tenth Century to Third Century B.C.)—The Influence of Confucianism—His Agnosticism—Weakening of Supernatural Beliefs—Consolidation of Confucianism—Human Sacrifices—Prayers for Rain—The Philosophy of Taoism—A Rival to Confucianism—But uniting to weaken the old Monotheistic Faith—Its Theory of Spirits—Modifications of Taoism—The Elixir of Life—Evidences of a Spiritual World—Mysticism. The Empire (Third Century B.C. to modern times)—Arguments against a Spiritual…
Passage [3]
← Chapter I: The Ancient Faith Religions of Ancient China by Herbert Allen Giles Chapter II — Confucianism Chapter III: Taoism → sister projects : Wikipedia article 110942 Religions of Ancient China — Chapter II — Confucianism Herbert Allen Giles Attitude of Confucius .—Under the influence of Confucius, B.C. 551-479, the old order of things began to undergo a change. The Sage's attitude of mind towards religion was one of a benevolent agnosticism, as summed up in his famous utterance, "Respect the spirits, but keep them at a distance." That he fully recognised the existence of a spirit world,…
Passage [39]
ion, rather than in this out-of-the-way barbarous region, where for centuries there has been no one to enjoy its beauty. And so, on the other hand, such waste of labour and incongruity of position disposed me to think that there could not be a God after all." Letter from God.—In A.D. 1008 there was a pretended revelation from God in the form of a letter, recalling the letter from Christ on the neglect of the Sabbath mentioned by Roger of Wendover and Hoveden, contemporary chroniclers. The Emperor and his Court regarded this communication with profound awe; but a high official of the day said,…
Passage [74]
he replied, "I do not murmur against God. I do not mumble against man. My studies lie low, and my penetration lies high. But there is God; He knows me." We know that Confucius fasted, and we know that "he sacrificed to the spirits as though the spirits were present;" it is even stated that "when a friend sent him a present, though it might be a carriage and horses, unless it were flesh which had been used in sacrifice, he did not bow." He declared that for a person in mourning food and music were without flavour and charm; and whenever he saw anyone approaching who was in mourning dress, even…
Passage [41]
rmed by villagers when driving out evil spirits from their dwellings. He protested against any attempt to impose on God. He said that "he who offends against God has none to whom he can pray;" and when in an hour of sickness a disciple asked to be allowed to pray for him, he replied, "My praying has been for a long time." Yet he declined to speak to his disciples of God, of spiritual beings or even of death and a hereafter, holding that life and its problems were alone sufficient to tax the energies of the human race. While not altogether ignoring man's duty towards God, he subordinated it in…
Passage [42]

More questions about this book