Synthesized answer
An English teacher using Blakely's book might reconcile his disclaimer of dogmatism with his use of an "tone of authority for the sake of brevity" by understanding that the authority is a rhetorical tool. Blakely states, "If I have anywhere assumed a tone of authority, it has been merely for the sake of brevity in stating my opinions" [1]. This suggests that the authoritative tone is not meant to impose rigid rules but to present his recommendations concisely.
Therefore, a teacher could adapt Blakely's plans by recognizing that the authoritative statements are intended to efficiently convey his suggestions, rather than to dictate inflexible methods. The teacher can then select and modify these suggestions to suit their specific classroom needs and the conditions under which they work, as Blakely himself notes, "Each teacher, of course, must work out his own plan in accordance with the needs of his pupils and the conditions under which he works" [2]. The book is presented "in the hope that they may be suggestive to teachers" [2], implying that the plans are a starting point for adaptation rather than a rigid curriculum.
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
llow teacher's plans of work. I wish to disclaim any desire to dogmatize about the methods or the details of teaching. If I have anywhere assumed a tone of authority, it has been merely for the sake of brevity in stating my opinions. Three books on the teaching of English have recently appeared: _The Teaching of English_ by Percival Chubb, _The Teaching of English_ by Professors Carpenter, Baker, and Scott, and _Talks on Teaching Literature_ by Arlo Bates. All of these are full of inspiration and suggestion for me as they doubtless are for hundreds of others; they ought to be within…
Produced by Peter Vachuska, Marcia Brooks, Chuck Greif and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net TEACHERS' OUTLINES FOR STUDIES IN ENGLISH BASED ON THE REQUIREMENTS FOR ADMISSION TO COLLEGE BY GILBERT SYKES BLAKELY, A. M. INSTRUCTOR IN ENGLISH IN THE MORRIS HIGH SCHOOL NEW YORK CITY [Illustration] NEW YORK CINCINNATI CHICAGO AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY COPYRIGHT, 1908, BY GILBERT SYKES BLAKELY ENTERED AT STATIONERS' HALL, LONDON STUDIES IN ENGLISH W. P. 5 PREFACE The following plans of study for the…
r suggestions concerning the plan of the book and certain of its details, I am under obligations to Dr. Henry van Dyke. I desire also to express my thanks for helpful criticism to several of my fellow teachers in the Morris High School, especially to Mr. Harold E. Foster who has kindly read most of the manuscript. G. S. BLAKELY. THE MORRIS HIGH SCHOOL.
of this kind, since it is the essay that the student himself, in his school exercises, is continually trying to write. Care should be taken at this stage of the work not to ask pupils to discuss matters that are beyond their knowledge. GENERAL PLAN FOR THE STUDY OF THE ESSAY I. Preparation Complete understanding of the matters that the essayist expects his readers to know usually involves more study than the class have time to give. Carlyle in his _Essay on Burns_ takes for granted the reader's familiarity with the poetry of Burns and the facts of his life, while probably only…
by one phase of his work and fail to see, or to see in due proportion, other phases equally, or even more, important. As a rule, the limitations of time make it impossible thoroughly to investigate many lines of study, and the teacher naturally follows his own taste in making selections. Now the average high school student has limitations which we are bound to recognize. Accustomed as he is to reading fiction where description and explanation are frequently used to aid the imagination and the understanding, he fails to appreciate the situations in a drama and the motives for the…
More questions about this book
- Explain, as if to a fellow student, the precise problem Blakely's "Teachers' Outlines" aims to solve for English teachers, and how his approach differs from the "discussion of the principles of teaching" offered by the other authors he mentions.
- Given that these outlines are "based on the requirements for admission to college," what does this text imply about the relationship between secondary school English curriculum and university expectations in 1908?
- Considering the specific literary works listed in the Contents, such as _Ivanhoe_ or _The Ancient Mariner_, what specific skills or critical understandings do you infer college admissions boards of 1908 were testing through these texts?
- If you were an English teacher reading this preface, what would you anticipate to be the *most practical* type of guidance or insight you would gain from the "application of certain principles" within these outlines?