Synthesized answer
Gide states his intention for the book was "as little an indictment as an apology" and that he "took care to pass no judgment" [1, 2]. He observed that readers, however, "reprobate him [Michel] with all the superiority of their kind hearts" and felt indignation "in spite of me" [2]. Gide suggests this reader reaction occurs because the public "will not forgive an author who, after relating an action, does not declare himself either for or against it" [1].
This phenomenon suggests a challenge to authorial neutrality, as readers desire the author to "take sides" [1]. The passages indicate that even when an author intends to present a situation without judgment, the reader's personal reactions can lead them to form strong opinions about the characters, sometimes projecting those feelings onto the author themselves [2]. Gide notes that readers were "grateful to me for the indignation he felt against my hero; it was as though he felt this indignation in spite of me; it overflowed from Michel on to myself" [2]. The passages do not explicitly delve into the power dynamics of authorial neutrality beyond this observation of reader response.
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
ded with him. But I intended to make this book as little an indictment as an apology and took care to pass no judgment. The public now-a-days will not forgive an author who, after relating an action, does not declare himself either for or against it; more than this, during the very course of the drama they want him to take sides, pronounce in favour either of Alceste or Philinte, of Hamlet or Ophelia, of Faust or Margaret, of Adam or Jehovah. I do not indeed claim that neutrality (I was going to say ‘indecision’) is the certain mark of a great mind; but I believe that many great minds…
your thirst is a still more cruel fierceness--yet lying on the golden sand they are not without a beauty of their own. If I had held my hero up as an example, it must be admitted that my success would have been small. The few readers who were disposed to interest themselves in Michel’s adventure did so only to reprobate him with all the superiority of their kind hearts. It was not in vain that I had adorned Marceline with so many virtues; they could not forgive Michel for not preferring her to himself. If I had intended this book to be an indictment of Michel, I should have succeeded…
cene of it is laid in my hero’s soul, is nevertheless too general to remain circumscribed in his individual adventure. I do not pretend to have invented this ‘problem’; it existed before my book; whether Michel triumph or succumb, the ‘problem’ will continue to exist, and the author has avoided taking either triumph or defeat for granted. If certain distinguished minds have refused to see in this drama anything but the exposition of a special case, and in its hero anything but a sufferer from disease, if they have failed to recognize that ideas of very urgent import and very general…
rs. But the real interest of a work and the interest taken in it by an ephemeral public are two very different things. A man may, I think, without much conceit, take the risk of not arousing immediate interest in interesting things--he may even prefer this to exciting a momentary delight in a public greedy only for sweets and trifles. For the rest, I have not tried to prove anything, but only to paint my picture well and to set it in a good light. I WILL PRAISE THEE; FOR I AM FEARFULLY AND WONDERFULLY MADE …
ody to the passers-by. She is very beautiful and in the first weeks I sometimes allowed her to pass the night with me. But one morning, her brother, little Ali, surprised us together. He showed great annoyance and refused to come back for five days. And yet he knows perfectly well how and on what his sister lives; he used to speak of it before without the slightest embarrassment.... Can he be jealous? Be that as it may, the little rascal has succeeded in his object; for, partly from distaste, partly because I was afraid of losing Ali, I have given the woman up since this incident.…
More questions about this book
- Explain what Gide means by describing his book as a "fruit filled with bitter ashes" and "colocinths of the desert." How does this metaphor illuminate the *experience* of engaging with "The Immoralist" for a reader, especially in light of Gide's stated refusal to pass judgment?
- The preface highlights the public's desire for authors to "declare himself either for or against it" and to "take sides." How might Gide's refusal to "conclude" or pass judgment on Michel challenge conventional expectations of storytelling and the moral responsibilities readers often assign to authors?
- Gide suggests that "to state a problem clearly is not to suppose it solved in advance." Based on the preface, what "problem" do you anticipate *The Immoralist* might be exploring, and how does Gide's neutral, non-judgmental approach allow for a deeper, more complex exploration of this problem than taking a definitive stance?
- If Gide intentionally refrained from judging Michel, how does this authorial choice shift the burden of interpretation and moral judgment from the author to the reader? What analytical strategies would a reader need to employ to understand Michel's character and actions fully *without* the author's guiding judgment?