← The Destinies of the Stars

Question

The translator highlights Arrhenius's "hearty abhorrence" of "purposiveness" in natural science, yet presents his intellectual evolution as "strongest evidence in favour of that theory of 'purposiveness'." How do you reconcile this apparent contradiction, and what does it suggest about the distinct roles or perspectives of a natural scientist versus a philosopher?

Synthesized answer

The apparent contradiction of Arrhenius's "hearty abhorrence" of "purposiveness" in natural science while his intellectual evolution is presented as evidence for this theory can be reconciled by understanding the distinction between a natural scientist and a philosopher. The translator notes that Arrhenius justly abhors "purposiveness" when resorted to in natural science, but that this theory is nevertheless justly dear to the philosopher [1]. This suggests that while a natural scientist like Arrhenius would focus on empirical evidence and avoid teleological explanations within his scientific work, the overarching narrative of his intellectual journey, driven by a "divine yearning to reach ultimate causes," inadvertently supports the philosophical concept of purposiveness in the universe [2].

Arrhenius's own scientific endeavors, exemplified by his works in electro-chemistry and cosmological physics, demonstrate a progression from the "infinitely small" to the "infinitely large" [2]. This expansion of his research, as the passages indicate, leads to an overwhelming passion for understanding the "whole material universe, its whence and whither" [2]. While this deep engagement with…

Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.

From the book

faith may be, constitutes our strongest evidence in favour of that theory of “purposiveness” in the universe which Dr. Arrhenius so heartily abhors (and justly so) when resorted to in natural science, but which theory nevertheless (and justly so) is so dear to the philosopher:--_Researches in Regard to the Conductivity of Electrolytes; Conductivity of Extremely Diluted Solutions; Chemical Theory of Electrolytes; Textbook in Theoretical Electro-Chemistry; Textbook in Cosmological Physics; Worlds in the Making; Infinity of the Universe; Life of the Universe as Conceived by Man from…
Passage [3]
he NOBEL PRIZE in Chemistry it came as a fitting reward of his achievements principally in the electro-chemical field. It was natural, however, that a genius of his calibre would not limit his interest to the “infinitely small” but would gradually broaden it to encompass the “infinitely large.” And “to take an interest” means with Dr. Arrhenius to push the boundaries of the unknown and of the unexplored a little farther away from man. His evolution in this respect runs parallel with that of all the great men who stand out as leaders in the history of science. Wrapt up in the solution…
Passage [2]
Destinies of the Stars_? The volume came as inevitably as fruition follows flowering. What remains to be seen is if Dr. Arrhenius can withstand the tremendous temptation that must be at work in his soul to lift, be it ever so little, the curtain that separates natural science and philosophy; we hope he will give in; we admire in this book how he reads “The Riddle of the Milky Way”; we certainly wish to know how he reads--the riddle of the universe. _The Destinies of the Stars_ met with unexampled success in Sweden. Three editions appeared within two months when the book was published in…
Passage [4]
ess in astronomy and kindred sciences is nowadays made at a dizzying speed if measured with the standard of antiquity. Occasionally we hear a warning voice asking us to show more deference to a philosophy directly descending from the Platonic-Aristotelian. He who is at all familiar with the history of natural science will understand us when we answer: “We have had more than enough thereof.” That non-naturalists sometimes have a peculiar conception of the present status of astronomy is well illustrated by the statement of one of our foremost theologians in a review of a popular…
Passage [56]
een added, chiefly based on the most recent astronomical discoveries some of which have been recorded as late as 1917. For valuable suggestions and for all the American equivalents of the metric measures in the original, the reader as well as the translator, is indebted to a member of the Publishing House that presents this volume in such an attractive way, Mr. E. W. Putnam, himself an ardent lover of astronomy and a writer on the subject. Dr. Arrhenius is justly renowned for his lucid style and polished form. All that is lacking in these qualities within the covers of this volume is…
Passage [5]

More questions about this book