← The Celtic Twilight

Question

Yeats claims to have recorded "accurately and candidly much that I have heard and seen," yet also admits to "deceitful sentences" to protect story-tellers and asserts that "any who will can weave them into whatever garments of belief please them best." What does this suggest about his understanding of "accuracy" and "truth" in the context of folklore and artistic creation, and how might it differ from a purely historical account?

Synthesized answer

Yeats's understanding of "accuracy" and "truth" in the context of folklore and artistic creation appears to be multifaceted and distinct from a purely historical account. He claims to have recorded "accurately and candidly much that I have heard and seen" [2], suggesting an intention to preserve what he experienced. However, he also acknowledges the use of "deceitful sentences" to protect story-tellers [1], implying that absolute, unvarnished truth might harm individuals or compromise the integrity of their narratives.

This approach suggests that for Yeats, the "truth" of folklore can encompass subjective experience and the need for protective measures, rather than a strict adherence to verifiable facts. He asserts that "The things a man has heard and seen are threads of life, and if he pull them carefully from the confused distaff of memory, any who will can weave them into whatever garments of belief please them best" [2]. This highlights a belief that the raw material of lived experience, when presented, allows for individual interpretation and the construction of personal truths by the audience. This differs from a purely historical account, which typically aims for…

Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.

From the book

woven my garment like another, but I shall try to keep warm in it, and shall be well content if it do not unbecome me. Hope and Memory have one daughter and her name is Art, and she has built her dwelling far from the desperate field where men hang out their garments upon forked boughs to be banners of battle. O beloved daughter of Hope and Memory, be with me for a little. 1893. II I have added a few more chapters in the manner of the old ones, and would have added others, but one loses, as one grows older, something of the lightness of one’s dreams; one begins to take life up in…
Passage [3]
and the hope of his heart.” The host is rushing ’twixt night and day; And where is there hope or deed as fair? Caolte tossing his burning hair, And Niamh calling, “Away, come away.” THIS BOOK I I have desired, like every artist, to create a little world out of the beautiful, pleasant, and significant things of this marred and clumsy world, and to show in a vision something of the face of Ireland to any of my own people who would look where I bid them. I have therefore written down accurately and candidly much that I have heard and seen, and, except by way…
Passage [2]
and shall try to make it systematical and learned enough to buy pardon for this handful of dreams. 1902. W. B. YEATS. A TELLER OF TALES Many of the tales in this book were told me by one Paddy Flynn, a little bright-eyed old man, who lived in a leaky and one-roomed cabin in the village of Ballisodare, which is, he was wont to say, “the most gentle”--whereby he meant faery--“place in the whole of County Sligo.” Others hold it, however, but second to Drumcliff and Drumahair. The first time I saw him he was cooking mushrooms for himself; the next time he was asleep under a hedge,…
Passage [4]
not moods which need heaven, hell, purgatory, and faeryland for their expression, no less than this dilapidated earth? Nay, are there not moods which shall find no expression unless there be men who dare to mix heaven, hell, purgatory, and faeryland together, or even to set the heads of beasts to the bodies of men, or to thrust the souls of men into the heart of rocks? Let us go forth, the tellers of tales, and seize whatever prey the heart long for, and have no fear. Everything exists, everything is true, and the earth is only a little dust under our feet. BELIEF AND…
Passage [7]
ne, and she put her head down on the table and began to cry, and she cried so he was afraid her husband might be angry. He was afraid to ask what had happened to Byrne, and left soon after, never to see her again. When the old man had finished the story, he said, “Tell that to Mr. Yeats, he will make a poem about it, perhaps.” But the daughter said, “Oh no, father. Nobody could make a poem about a woman like that.” Alas! I have never made the poem, perhaps because my own heart, which has loved Helen and all the lovely and fickle women of the world, would be too sore. There are things…
Passage [54]

More questions about this book