Synthesized answer
Hamsun's objective of combating "artificial uselessness" manifests differently in "Hunger" and "Growth of the Soil" by the *mode of his attack* and the *intensity of his feeling* [4]. In his earlier works, like "Hunger," he used an "open attack in full force" with novels dealing "sarcastically with the literary Bohemia" [5]. This approach, however, was considered artistically a failure [5]. In contrast, "Growth of the Soil" celebrates the life of the open country for its own sake, rather than merely as a contrast to city artificiality [1]. Hamsun's protagonist, Isak, is presented as a "simple pioneer," an "inarticulate and uncouth personification of man's mastery of nature" [2]. This work represents his "ultimate self-discovery" and withdrawal from urban gathering places to focus on the land [1].
From Hamsun's perspective, artificiality is embodied in the "life of the city" and the "ambitions and Utopias bred within them" [4, 3]. This is contrasted with the "simplicity" he places above other virtues [3]. The essence of artificiality, therefore, appears to be its disconnection from what Hamsun considers fundamental and natural. The passages do not explicitly define the essence of…
Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.
From the book
ties. But no one that I can recall has equalled Hamsun in his merciless denunciation of the very principle of urbanity. The truth of it seems to be that Hamsun's pilgrimage to the bee hives where modern humanity clusters typically, was an essential violation of something within himself that mattered even more than his literary ambition to his soul's integrity. Perhaps, if I am right, he is the first genuine peasant who has risen to such artistic mastery, reaching its ultimate heights through a belated recognition of his own proper settings. Hamsun was sixty when he wrote “Growth of…
t is, in a way, but only in so far as we have come to think of social and urban as more or less interchangeable terms. He has a social consciousness and a social passion of his own, but it is decentralized, one might say. He knows of no greater man than his own Isak of “Growth of the Soil”--a simple pioneer in whose wake new homes spring up, an inarticulate and uncouth personification of man's mastery of nature. When Hamsun speaks of Isak passing across the yearning, spring-stirred fields, “with the grain flung in fructifying waves from his reverent hands,” he pictures…
its connection or lack of connection with that substance. Taking it all in all, one may well call Hamsun old-fashioned. The virtues winning his praise and the conditions that stir his longings are not of the present day. There is in him something primitive that forms a sharp contrast to the modernity of his own style. Even in his most romantic exaggerations, as in “Hunger” and “Mysteries,” he is a realist, dealing unrelentingly with life as it appears to us. It would hardly be too much to call his method scientific. But he uses it to aim tremendous explosive charges at those human…
d. His objective is the same. If he has changed, it is only in the intensity of his feeling and the mode of his attack. What, above all, he hates and combats is the artificial uselessness of existence which to him has become embodied in the life of the city as opposed to that of the country. Problems do not enter into the novels of Hamsun in the same manner as they did into the plays of Ibsen. Hamsun would seem to take life as it is, not with any pretense at its complete acceptability, but without hope or avowed intention of making it over. If his tolerance be never free from satire,…
s ultimate self-discovery. The various phases of his campaign against city life are also interesting and illuminating. Early in his career as a writer he tried an open attack in full force by a couple of novels, “Shallow Soil” and “Editor Lynge”, dealing sarcastically with the literary Bohemia of the Norwegian capital. They were, on the whole, failures--artistically rather than commercially. They are among his poorest books. The attack was never repeated in that form. He retired to the country, so to speak, and tried from there to strike at what he could reach of the ever expanding,…
More questions about this book
- Explain Hamsun's core artistic objective—his opposition to the "artificial uselessness of existence"—in simple terms, then describe how his approach to societal problems differs fundamentally from Ibsen's, as if you were clarifying it for a non-expert.
- The text states Hamsun's satire is "easily tolerant" and he relates brutalities with an "offhandedness of manner." How do these seemingly detached narrative choices serve his "deceptive" artistry and contribute to his overall objective of combating artificiality, rather than undermining it?
- If Ibsen's central concern was the individual's struggle "to be himself," and Hamsun "begins where Ibsen ended" by taking this self-expression for granted, what new categories of human conflict or meaning might Hamsun's works explore, and why?
- How can Hamsun simultaneously "hate and combat" the artificiality of existence while also viewing life as "static" and reform as "intrinsically unachievable"? What does this apparent paradox reveal about his understanding of human agency and the nature of the problems he addresses?