← Elmer Gantry

Question

Elmer's voice is described as profoundly impactful, capable of making simple greetings seem "profound as Kant." Explain how this specific detail, juxtaposed with his current state and actions, foreshadows his role and potential for manipulation within the narrative.

Synthesized answer

Elmer's voice is described as profoundly impactful, capable of making simple greetings seem "profound as Kant" [4]. This 'arousing barytone' is further characterized as a 'cello,' a voice that can deliver simple phrases with the welcoming quality of a brass band and the uplifting power of a cathedral organ [4]. Despite this immense vocal talent, the passages also reveal that Elmer learned "nothing except the placing of his voice" in his Public Speaking class, and that he had "never been a failure nor ever for one second interesting" in his orations [3]. He was noted to steal ideas and phrasing from the encyclopedia [3].

This juxtaposition of a gifted voice with a lack of substantive content and a history of uninspired delivery foreshadows his potential for manipulation. His ability to make mundane statements profound [4] suggests he can use his vocal prowess to create an illusion of depth and importance, masking a potential emptiness in his message or intentions. The detail that he learned "nothing except the placing of his voice" [3] highlights that his skill lies in presentation rather than genuine insight, a characteristic ripe for exploitation in influencing others.

Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.

From the book

from cradle to tomb inspires art etc. music voice of love slam atheists etc. who not appreciate love “Guess you must be a newspaperman, Brother,” a voice assailed him. Elmer looked at his seatmate, a little man with a whisky nose and asterisks of laughter-wrinkles round his eyes, a rather sportingly dressed little man with the red tie which in 1906 was still thought rather the thing for socialists and drinkers. He could have a good time with such a little man, Elmer considered. A drummer. Would it be more fun to be natural with him, or to ask him if he…
Passage [300]
But he would recover again, and he was a promise of what he might be in twenty years, as a ten-thousand-dollar seer. He had grown broader, his glossy hair, longer than at Terwillinger, was brushed back from his heavy white brow, his nails were oftener clean, and his speech was Jovian. It was more sonorous, more measured and pontifical; he could, and did, reveal his interested knowledge of your secret moral diabetes merely by saying, “How are we today, Brother?” And though he had almost flunked in Greek, his thesis on “Sixteen Ways of Paying a Church Debt” had won the ten-dollar…
Passage [157]
one looked at him respectfully, Elmer tried to prepare his address for the Y. M. C. A. and affiliated lady worshipers. Jim was sleeping, with a snore like the snarl of a leopard. In his class in Public Speaking, a course designed to create congressmen, bishops, and sales-managers, Elmer had had to produce discourses on Taxation, the Purpose of God in History, Our Friend the Dog, and the Glory of the American Constitution. But his monthly orations had not been too arduous; no one had grieved if he stole all his ideas and most of his phrasing from the encyclopedia. The most important…
Passage [114]
red to a table to nourish the long, rich, chocolate strains suitable to drunken melody. Actually, they sang very well. Jim had a resolute tenor, and as to Elmer Gantry, even more than his bulk, his thick black hair, his venturesome black eyes, you remembered that arousing barytone. He was born to be a senator. He never said anything important, and he always said it sonorously. He could make “Good morning” seem profound as Kant, welcoming as a brass band, and uplifting as a cathedral organ. It was a ’cello, his voice, and in the enchantment of it you did not hear his slang, his…
Passage [3]
s valuable in business as in the church, the class to which he gave the most reverent attention was that of Mr. Ben T. Bohnsock, “Professor of Oratory and Literature, and Instructor in Voice Culture.” Under him, Elmer had been learning an ever more golden (yet steel-strong) pulpit manner, learning not to split infinitives in public, learning that references to Dickens, Victor Hugo, James Whitcomb Riley, Josh Billings, and Michelangelo give to a sermon a very toney Chicago air. Elmer’s eloquence increased like an August pumpkin. He went into the woods to practise. Once a small boy came…
Passage [245]

More questions about this book