The Jubilee of the Constitution (1839)

Question

Adams highlights the diverse origins of the colonists ("heterogeneously composed") yet claims they shared "one clear, steady flame of liberty, kindled at different furnaces, but all furnaces of affliction." How might the experience of "affliction" from varied backgrounds have uniquely prepared this diverse group to forge a unified nation, and what potential difficulties might it also have presented?

Synthesized answer

The experience of "affliction" from varied backgrounds uniquely prepared the diverse colonists to forge a unified nation by "steel[ing] to energetic and unyielding hardihood the characters of the primitive settlers of all these colonies" [1]. These settlers were "well weaned from the delicate milk of our mother country, and inured to the difficulties of a strange land" [3]. Their shared "furnaces of affliction" kindled "one clear, steady flame of liberty" [1, 2]. They were "knit together in a strict and sacred bond, to take care of the good of each other and of the whole" and were not easily discouraged by small things [3, 5].

However, the passages also suggest potential difficulties. The colonists were "heterogeneously composed" of "sectarians, religious and political, of all the classes which for the two preceding centuries had agitated and divided the people of the British islands," and also included descendants of various European nationalities [2]. This diversity, coupled with experiences like being driven into exile due to differing religious views, could lead to internal conflict [4]. The passage notes that the founders of the Plymouth Colony, after suffering for their…

Synthesized from the book passages below. Chat with the book on Feynman for follow-up.

From the book

there was burning, kindled at different furnaces, but all furnaces of affliction, one clear, steady flame of liberty. Bold and daring enterprise, stubborn endurance of privation, unflinching intrepidity in facing danger, and inflexible adherence to conscientious principle, had steeled to energetic and unyielding hardihood the characters of the primitive settlers of all these colonies. Since that time two or three generations of men had passed away, but they had increased and multiplied with unexampled rapidity; and the land itself had been the recent theatre of a ferocious and bloody…
Passage [6]
Yes, gentlemen, on that shield the Constitution of the United States was sculptured (by forms unseen, and in characters then invisible to mortal eye), the predestined and prophetic history of the one confederated people of the North American Union. They had been the settlers of thirteen separate and distinct English colonies, along the margin of the shore of the North American Continent; contiguously situated, but chartered by adventurers of characters variously diversified, including sectarians, religious and political, of all the classes which for the two preceding centuries had…
Passage [5]
gned so many comforts and enjoyments at home; but their hearts panted for a restoration to the bosom of their country. Invited and urged by the open-hearted and truly benevolent people who had given them an asylum from the persecution of their own kindred to form their settlement within the territories then under their jurisdiction, the love of their country predominated over every influence save that of conscience alone, and they preferred the precarious chance of relaxation from the bigoted rigor of the English Government to the certain liberality and alluring offers of the…
Passage [38]
eir own preference, and, of course, upon that of non-conformity to the establishment prescribed by the royal authority. The only means used to convince them of error and reclaim them from dissent was force, and force served but to confirm the opposition it was meant to suppress. By driving the founders of the Plymouth Colony into exile, it constrained them to absolute separation irreconcilable. Viewing their religious liberties here, as held only by sufferance, yet bound to them by all the ties of conviction, and by all their sufferings for them, could they forbear to look upon every…
Passage [57]
could discourage, or small discontents cause to wish themselves again at home." Children of these exalted Pilgrims! Is there one among you who can hear the simple and pathetic energy of these expressions without tenderness and admiration? Venerated shades of our forefathers! No, ye were, indeed, not ordinary men! That country which had ejected you so cruelly from her bosom you still delighted to contemplate in the character of an affectionate and beloved mother. The sacred bond which knit you together was indissoluble while you lived; and oh, may it be to your descendants the…
Passage [39]

More questions about this book